6.7.8.4 Risks in Ignoring the Problems of Change
There are risks in ignoring the problems of change, which can be exploited by populist politicians
The preceding sub-sections have focused on how politicians can respond proactively to rapid social change, but too many have simply ignored the problems of people who have been harmed by it. People in several countries became disillusioned with mainstream politicians (6.3.9), feeling that recent governments had not listened to them or understood their problems.
People can experience status anxiety (4.3.2.3) when they have lost their jobs. They may be prepared to listen to anyone who offers to fix their problems:
● They might follow populist politicians who attack the political establishment, possibly putting the democracy itself at risk. This was illustrated when Donald Trump galvanized his supporters to storm the Capitol building on 6 January 2021, falsely alleging that the 2020 election had been stolen from him.
● An appeal to nationalism can help a politician to build a sense of shared identity among people who feel resentful about how their country is changing. Trump promised to “make America great again” and, as described earlier, politicians with similar messages are gaining support in several advanced economies (6.3.2.6).
● People who are suffering become vulnerable to believing in conspiracy theories that offer comforting but ludicrous explanations of their plight (6.4.2.7). Trump welcomed their support. The BBC report on the Capitol riots: Who broke into the building? noted their presence in the storming of the Capitol referred to above.
● Some people can be persuaded to believe that they are innately superior to others, which comforts them when they are suffering financially. This ‘alt-right’ narrative has been exploited by politicians in several countries, including America (6.2.4.6). White supremacist militias took part in the assault on the Capitol.
Donald Trump was elected because both political parties had unconsciously taken risks in ignoring the problems of change. The storming of the Capitol building was the culmination of his determination to hang onto power in 2021. It failed, but the threat to America’s democracy remains. Trump has become overtly authoritarian in his second term of office. He is following the recommendations of a Heritage Foundation vision document, Project 2025: “a 900-page policy “wish list”, a set of proposals that would expand presidential power and impose an ultra-conservative social vision.” “he has nominated several of its authors to fill key government positions, and many of his initial executive orders closely follow proposals outlined in the document.”
America is not the only country whose democracy is under threat from an authoritarian populist. A European report finds waning of democracy in Poland, Hungary: it “deemed Poland deficient in the four main areas reviewed: national justice systems, anti-corruption frameworks, media freedom and checks and balances” and in “Hungary, government-sponsored laws targeting media freedoms, minority rights, the electoral system and academic and religious freedoms drew the commission’s notice”.
This page is intended to form part of Edition 4 of the Patterns of Power series of books. An archived copy of it is held at https://www.patternsofpower.org/edition04/6784a.htm.